Application of multi-criteria analysis for the selection of power supply system for electrification new lines in the existing railway network energized by 3 KV DC system
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.61089/aot2025.rv42ms78Keywords:
railway electrification, AC and DC power supply system, multi-criteria analysis, eco-nomic criteria, TSI criteriaAbstract
Electrified railways are practically the only mass transport system meeting sustain-able transport requirements of the European Green Deal policy, driving the inter-est, worldwide and in Europe, in constructing new railway lines or modernizing the existing ones. Due to differences between power supply systems in Europe, TSI standards have been issued to make railways interoperable. When a new high-speed rail line is to be built, it uses AC power supply system as it has larger power capac-ity than DC systems. However, in some countries, like Poland, a vast railway net-work is electrified with 3 kV DC. There are plans for intensive construction of new railway lines, building interconnections between the existing ones, or high-speed lines Warsaw-Łódź-Poznań/Wrocław (electrified with 25 kV AC). This raises a problem: which power supply system should be chosen for these new lines: the existing 3 kV DC or the new 25 kV AC? This paper proposes a new approach help-ful in undertaking such decisions for a specific line with the application of multi-criteria analysis (MCA), considering economic and non-economic criteria. Specific circumstances of Polish railway lines (12150 km electrified under 3 kV DC) and other aspects, such as grid network availability, construction time, and usage of the existing infrastructure, are also considered. The novelty of the presented in the paper research is seen in identification and scaling criteria for application in MCA to support decision making (MCDM) which type of a power supply system 3 kV DC or 25 kV 50 Hz is optimal to be chosen for a specific railway line in an area of densely spread existing railway lines supplied by 3 kV DC system. A review and discussion of the available in the literature research on MCA applied for MCDM in area of energy systems is enclosed, when conflicting qualitative and quantitative criteria are to be taken into account. Examples of application of the MCA method to support undertaking decision on type of a power supply for railway lines planned to be electrified are as well presented.
References
1. Analysis of costs and benefits of investment projects in the transport sector, Blue Book - Railway projects. Annex I Part 2 - 2006 edition
2. Burak-Romanowski R.(2025, February 6)- Electrification of PKP PLK S.A. railway network (in Polish)- Elektryfikacja sieci kolejowej PKP Polskich Linii Kolejowych S.A., presentation PKP PLK S.A.
3. Commission Regulation (EU) No 1301/2014 of 18 November 2014 on the technical specifications for interoperability relating to the ‘energy’ subsystem of the rail system in the Union (Text with EEA relevance) http://data.europa.eu/eli/reg/2014/1301/2023-09-28
4. Commission Regulation (EU) No 1299/2014 of 18 November 2014 on the technical specifications for interoperability relating to the ‘infrastructure’ subsystem of the rail system in the European Union (Text with EEA relevance), http://data.europa.eu/eli/reg/2014/1299/2023-09-28
5. D’Agostino G., Zio E., Heckmann I. (2022). Railway Infrastructure Maintenance and Replacement: A Risk-Informed Decision-Making, Approach. Reliable. Eng. Syst. Saf. 2022, 223, 108536
6. Dean M. (2022). A Practical Guide to Multi-Criteria Analysis Technical Report, January 2022 doi: 10.13140/RG.2.2.15007.02722
7. de Oliveira, V.A.R., Salomon, V.A.P., De Oliveira, G.C.R., Petrillo, A., Neves, S.M. (2023). Systematic Literature Review of Multi-criteria Decision-Making Applied to Energy Management. In: Fathi, M., Zio, E., Pardalos, P.M. (eds) Handbook of Smart Energy Systems. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-97940-9_113
8. Dolinayová A., Döménya I., Abramović B., Šipuš D.(2023). Electrified and non-electrified railway infrastructure - economic efficiency of rail vehicle change Transportation Research Procedia 74, 93–100. TRANSCOM 2023: 15th International Scientific Conference on Sustainable, Modern and Safe Transport
9. Eurail (2025) FP3, WP14 Objectives and Deliverables. Available online: access 19.03.2025 https://projects.rail-research.europa.eu/eurail-fp3/structure/
10. Grzeszczyk T.(2010). A Multi-criteria analysis in assessment of European projects (in Polish - Analiza wielokryterialna w ocenie projektów europejskich), OW PW (Warsaw University of Technology Publishing House)
11. https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-eurostat-news/w/ddn-20240313-1, retrieved December 10,2024
12. https://www.cpk.pl/en/, retrieved December 10, 2024
13. Jacyna, M. (2001).Multi-criteria modeling in application to assessment of transport systems (in Polish -Modelowanie wielokryterialne w zastosowaniu do oceny systemów transportowych) pp.3-139, Prace Naukowe Politechniki Warszawskiej. Transport 47
14. Jacyna, M., Wasiak M. (2015). Multi-criteria decision support in designing transport systems." Tools of Transport Telematics: 15th International Conference on Transport Systems Telematics, TST 2015, Wrocław, Poland, April 15-17, 2015. Selected Papers 15. Springer International Publishing
15. Jaspers (2023).Blue book -Railway sector. Railway infrastructure (in Polish: Niebieska księga, Sektor kolejowy. Infrastruktura kolejowa)
16. Jefimowski, W., & Szeląg, A. (2018). The multi-criteria optimization method for implementation of a regenerative inverter in a 3 kV DC traction system. Electric Power Systems Research, 161, 61-73., https://doi.org/10.1016/j.epsr.2018.03.023
17. Jiang-Jiang Wang , You-Yin Jing, Chun-Fa Zhang, Jun-Hong Zhao-Review on multi-criteria decision analysis aid in sustainable energy decision-making, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 13 (2009) 2263–2278, doi:10.1016/j.rser.2009.06.021
18. Ling Zhang, Peng Zhou, Sidney Newton, Jian-xin Fang, De-qun Zhou , Lu-ping Zhang (2015).-Evaluating clean energy alternatives for Jiangsu, China:An improved multi-criteria decision making method, Energy 90,953-964. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2015.07.124
19. Kljaić, Z., Pavković, D., Cipek, M., Trstenjak, M., Mlinarić, T. J., & Nikšić, M. (2023). An Overview of Current Challenges and Emerging Technologies to Facilitate Increased Energy Efficiency, Safety, and Sustainability of Railway Transport. Future Internet, 15(11), 347. https://doi.org/10.3390/fi15110347
20. Lin, R., Ren, J. (2021). Overview of Multi-criteria Decision Analysis and Its Applications on Energy Systems. In: Ren, J. (eds) Energy Systems Evaluation (Volume 2). Green Energy and Technology (pp.1-26), Springer, Cham,
21. Massel, A. (2018) Operational criteria in the justification of electrification of railway lines, MATEC Web of Conferences 2018, Vol. 180, 06005,1-5 https://www.matec_conferences.org/articles/matecconf/abs/2018/39/matecconf_met2018_06005/matecconf_met2018_06005.html
22. Massel, A.(2018) Impact of line electrification on operation of railways, Proceedings of 22nd International Scientific Conference. Transport Means
23. Nezhad E., Nardelli A.(2023). Multiple-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) Applications in Optimizing Multi-objective Energy System Performance. In: Fathi, M., Zio, E., Pardalos, P.M. (eds) Handbook of Smart Energy Systems. Springer, Cham.
24. Nowotarski, P., & Gajzler, M. (2024). Improving Procedures for Maintaining Existing Railway Station Infrastructure in Poland as an Element of the Sustainable European Ecological Transformation. Sustainability, 16(22), 10124. https://doi.org/10.3390/su162210124
25. PN-EN 50163: 2006 – Railway applications - Supply voltages of traction systems
26. PN EN50122-3-2017 – Railway applications - Fixed installations - Electrical safety, earthing and the return circuit - Part 3: Mutual Interaction of AC and DC traction systems
27. PN-EN 50-367:2021-06 Railway applications – Fixed installations and rolling stock – Criteria to achieve technical compatibility between pantographs and overhead contact line
28. PN EN 50122-2 –2022 Railway applications - Fixed installations - Electrical safety, earthing and the return circuit Part 2: Provisions against the effects of stray currents caused by DC traction systems.
29. PN-EN 50388-1: 2023–05 Railway Applications- Fixed installations and rolling stock Technical criteria for the coordination between electric traction power supply systems and rolling stock to achieve interoperability-Part 1. General .
30. PN EN550122-1 2023–06 Railway applications -Fixed installations-Electrical safety, earthing and the return circuit-Part 1: Protective provisions against electric shock.
31. Pomykala, A.; Szelag, A. (2022). Reduction of Power Consumption and CO2 Emissions as a Result of Putting into Service High-Speed Trains: Polish Case. Energies 2022, 1-15, 4206. https://doi.org/10.3390/en15124206
32. Railjournal-https://www.railjournal.com/fleet/baden-wurttemberg-rejects-hydrogen-as-diesel-alternative/ (access: 2.01.2025)
33. European Union Agency for Railways (2020) Report Fostering the Railway Sector through the European Green Deal
34. Schär, S., & Geldermann, J. (2021). Adopting Multiactor Multicriteria Analysis for the Evaluation of Energy Scenarios. Sustainability, 13(5), 2594. https://doi.org/10.3390/su13052594
35. Siskos E., Burgherr P. (2022). Multicriteria decision support for the evaluation of electricity supply resilience: Exploration of interacting criteria. European Journal of Operational Research, 298,(2),pp.611-626, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2021.07.026
36. System Pillar Consortium – Task 1 UIC and UNIFE (2024) Energy saving in Rail: Consumption assessment, efficiency improvement and saving strategies, overview report, Version 14, March
37. Technical Standards for modernization or construction of railway lines for speed Vmax 200 km/h for conventional rolling stock /250 km/h for tilting body rolling stock. (2022) (in Polish) PKP PLK S.A., https://www.plk-sa.pl/klienci-i-kontrahenci/akty-prawne-i-przepisy/standardy-techniczne
38. Taherdoost, H.;Madanchian, M. Multi-Criteria-Decision Making (MCDM) Methods and Concepts, Encyclopedia 2023, 3, 77–87. https://doi.org/10.3390/encyclopedia3010006
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Archives of Transport journal allows the author(s) to hold the copyright without restrictions.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
How to Cite
